September 21, 2023
Home » Mindfulness Meditation Debunked? – Medical Information Bulletin
Mindfulness Meditation Debunked? – Medical Information Bulletin
Mindfulness Meditation Debunked? – Medical Information Bulletin
Photograph by Marcus Aurelius @Pexels

Improved well being and well-being are on the forefront of mindfulness meditation advantages. With this apply constantly gaining traction, researchers wished to carry out a scientific trial for proof of its efficacy in bettering cognitive perform (consideration, reminiscence, processing pace, and govt functioning). Mindfulness coaching seems engaging for these seeking to strengthen abilities and enhance well being, however what does the analysis say? 

What’s mindfulness? 

Mindfulness meditation is introspective considering with clearly outlined targets of taking note of ideas, feelings, and one’s environment with out judgment.1 Usually, a purpose is to enhance focus as it is not uncommon to catch the thoughts wandering after which lose monitor of the duty at hand. As well as, practising mindfulness encourages individuals to cut back nerve-racking habits, unfavorable emotions, and unhealthy responses by turning into extra conscious, centered, and empathetic.

Mindfulness meditation may be inspired at school settings or comfortably within the privateness of your house. Some research have proven that mindfulness-based practices and stress discount methods help cognitive perform in adults.2 If true, partaking on this exercise could possibly be used therapeutically or for restoration from sure brain-based circumstances.

Does mindfulness meditation work? 

With many nonetheless making an attempt to recuperate from the pandemic and regain some normalcy of their lives, the surge within the recognition of mindfulness meditation continues. Nevertheless, a latest research2 suggests mindfulness meditation doesn’t work in addition to researchers thought, at the very least for sure parameters and populations. 

A research printed in JAMA got down to take a look at the effectiveness of a mindfulness-based stress discount program.2 Contributors had been divided into teams with one group present process a mindfulness meditation intervention to enhance cognitive functioning.2 Cognitive perform was examined and evaluated based mostly on abilities together with self-regulation and adaptive considering (the flexibility to shortly assume with out getting confused). The analysis included a working and episodic reminiscence take a look at, a card sorting take a look at, and a consonant-vowel odd-even switching take a look at.2 

The intervention group was in comparison with a management group that didn’t bear mindfulness coaching.2 The management group was offered well being schooling with the identical class schedule because the mindfulness group concerning frequency and length. Nevertheless, no particular targets had been set for individuals throughout classes, and knowledge on mindfulness and train was excluded. On the six-month mark, there was no important distinction in cognitive functioning between the mindfulness and management teams.2 

Mindfulness meditation debunked? Possibly not.

Regardless of the unfavorable end result of no important distinction in cognitive perform between the teams, the authors emphasize that the research design might have influenced the outcomes. The researchers additionally acknowledge that different research have offered proof to counsel that mindfulness-based stress discount might enhance cognitive perform.2,3 Lastly, the inhabitants being studied is clearly an essential variable within the outcomes, and extra analysis is required to show or disprove a longtime practiced behavior as being with out worth.


  1. Wielgosz J, Goldberg SB, Kral TRA, Dunne JD, Davidson RJ. Mindfulness meditation and psychopathology. Annu Rev Clin Psychol. 2019;15:285-316.
  2. Lenze EJ et al. Results of mindfulness coaching and train on cognitive perform in older adults. JAMA. 2022;328(22):2218-2229.
  3. Whitfield T et al. The impact of mindfulness-based packages on cognitive perform in adults: A scientific overview and meta-analysis. Neuropsychology Evaluation. 2022;32:677-702.

Leave a Reply